Is Life a Dream?

This age-old philosophical puzzle is much more than an idle question.

post July 31, 2019 | the review by Davia Sills


*

One the the strange things about dreams is that many of the time, we aren’t mindful we’re dreaming. Typically, our memory and also our reflective capability are substantially minimal within dreams (Fosse et al. 2003; Hobson et al. 1998), leading to us no to notice incongruencies within the dream and to take because that granted the what we endure is real. It merely doesn’t take place to united state to think about whether it could not be.

You are watching: Is life a dream


Perhaps even an ext strangely, also when we perform on chance become mindful that we’re dreaming—and follow to various surveys brought out approximately the world, everywhere from 26 percent come 92 percent of world have had at the very least one lucid dream (Stepansky et al. 1998; Erlacher et al. 2008; Palmer 1979; Yu 2008)—the “sensory” experience of the dream deserve to remain simply as convincingly real. I remember in among my very own dreams, realizing the it was a dream and also then marveling at exactly how solid and also real the mobile in my hand quiet felt.


The capacity of the dream human being to appear real has actually led many thinkers—philosopher René Descartes (1641) gift the most prominent Western example—to wonder even if it is the human being we endure while awake can itself be a dream. If the dream civilization feels simply as genuine as the waking one (at least while we room in it), how deserve to we know for sure that we’re not right now living in a dream—a dream from which we may one day wake up up?


One way that philosophers have actually tried to dispel such worries is by appeal to differences between the dream world and also the waking one. For instance, ours waking people has a coherence that the dream people often lacks. (For an instance of a coherence-based argument against the hesitant hypothesis, view Norman Malcolm (1959).) You may recall the in the attribute film Inception, the characters learn to identify that they’re dreaming by questioning themselves just how they came to be in a particular situation, then realizing that they can not remember because the dream just dropped castle there.


But go the coherence of our waking people guarantee the it’s real?

I believe the coherence of our waking human being does provide us proof that the is not simply a figment of our imagination. Specifics it provides us proof that as soon as we are awake, other is causing our endure that is elevation of the endure itself. Because that instance, the relative permanence of the objects and environments we suffer in waking life would show up to be finest explained by there gift something real and also enduring the our experiences space reflecting.


However, the family member permanence of the objects and also environments us encounter in the waking human being is no guarantee that the waking human being is as real as the gets. After ~ all, a high degree of permanence is also found in the civilizations of video clip games, in i m sorry the “environments” and “objects” one interacts v are just the innovations of computer system code. So, while perceived permanence does it seems ~ to point to there being something target or enduring out there, the true nature of whatever is “out there” can resemble our suffer of that as small as computer system code each other the images we see once we play a video game.


In fact, physics teaches us that the objects we experience as gift solid are actually do up virtually entirely of north space. And the results of quantum mechanically experiments suggest that, under specific conditions, the building blocks of matter do not behave as discrete particles at all, yet rather together waves of probability. If we however experience the human being as complete of enduring, heavy objects, this is because of the usual means that ours senses interact with it and to the means these interaction are stood for in consciousness.


This method that there is, in fact, an essential sense in which all of us do continually live within a dream—that is, within a world created by our very own minds. It’s just that once we’re awake, our minds conform our dreaming to a reliable set of patterns, which we assume come be established by a fact that exists separately of our endure of it, despite we have no way of knowing that reality except through the complex ways in which it affects ours “dream.”


But might there be an even deeper sense in which our waking life is a dream?

Just together we often wake indigenous sleep to realize the what we were experiencing in the sleep state was not virtually as coherent and also “real” as what we experience as soon as awake, could there maybe come a day once we will emerge from the dream of waking truth to suffer a people that is even an ext coherent and vividly real, a state in which we suffer levels the knowledge, memory, and also other cognitive role that vastly surpass those we endure in our present lives?


In fact, a quite startling variety of people report having currently had experiences choose this. The is, they report having had experiences that show up to them as even an ext real 보다 those they have actually in their normal, waking state the mind. Because that example, “realer 보다 real” is a description often offered by those who have had actually near-death experiences (Moody 1975; Thonnard et al. 2013; Palmieri et al. 2014), those who have actually used psychedelic drugs such together DMT (Strassman 2001), and also those who, by miscellaneous other means, have experienced non-ordinary claims of consciousness.


Many near-death experiencers likewise report magnified cognitive function and a sudden increase in expertise (Owens et al. 1990; Greyson 2003). This perception of intensified cognitive role and raised knowledge is regularly dismissed together an illusion by those who are unfamiliar with the scientific literature on near-death experiences, yet careful investigation has shown that concrete, verifiable information has been acquired in these states which were not available to the experiencer by method of their 5 senses (Rivas et al. 2016).

See more: V=-Ed - Electrostatics


The experience of those who have tasted non-ordinary says of awareness raises the possibility that the age-old inquiry of even if it is “life is however a dream” is more than the idle worry of a few philosophers comfortable ensconced in their armchairs through the fire. The answer to this question could very well have major empirical consequences, consisting of startling ramifications for the types of experiences that are available to the human mind. We have every reason to remain alert come this possibility as we proceed to inspection the true nature the the people that us take ourselves come be life in.