it is registered Log InHome forums Handguns S&W 1911 vs Kimber 1911
ForumsUser ListCalendarActive ThreadsForum Help
previous Thread
Next object



You are watching: Smith and wesson 1911 e series vs kimber

*

RebaOP
OP

I recognize S&W"s are made in the USA.Not sure if the Kimbers a 100% USA.At and also rate who mades the better?Thanks
I have both & both are fine pistols & mine work-related perfectly but I"ve taken procedures to be certain that they do.If girlfriend cannot solve minor worries for yourself, today, i recommend S&W over Kimber because that a range of factors as ns think her likelihood of obtaining a good one appropriate out of package is a little higher.S&W also has a lifetime warranty; Kimber"s warranty & organization can be less than good..........I likewise don"t believe that a gun demands 500-1,000 ring to carry out reliably, however that is likely the reasonable you will gain with Kimber for any reliability concerns you may have throughout that duration with the gun. The mantra is "you need to break it in".If you obtain a S&W, acquire one that the more recent E-Series as it does not have actually the FPS system, unless, of course, you like that feature.MM
The Kimbers usually require a rest in period because they room fitted tight from the factory, something that is conductive to an excellent accuracy in 1911s so i hear.I poll Kimber.
Actually the smith and Wesson 1911"s space made in both the USA and Brazil. The USA ones room the ones come get. Ns looked in ~ two exact same brand-new s&W loaded design 1911"s critical week. One to be made in USA and one brazil and also they were completely different. The USA one was nicer.Kimbers space all make in NY, USA. They"re pretty too. If girlfriend are just going to have one acquire a steel structure 1911.
500-1000 ring to rest it in? Really? Seems favor a copout to me---don"t an insect us about your problems. Yet ns am hearing more and more tales of new gun buyers being told that. Can"t they do a device that reciprocates the slide and also dryfires the point for the forced period?I"m sure we"d not accept that reasoning from any other high dissension purchase. Together in: "I"m sorry Sir, however our refrigerators will malfunction for the first six months, friend know, girlfriend gotta rest them in for awhile". Or "We intentionally build our new Ford van to jam up in ~ highway speeds because that awhile--until it"s damaged in".I"d speak go through the one that insurance claims to work-related properly from the box. Who have the right to afford come waste 1000 rounds doing R&D the manufacturer should have done?
500-1000 rounds to rest it in? Really? Seems favor a copout to me---don"t an insect us about your problems. Yet i am hearing much more and more tales of new gun buyers being told that. Can"t they do a device that reciprocates the slide and dryfires the point for the forced period?I"m sure we"d no accept that thinking from any type of other high dissension purchase. Together in: "I"m sorry Sir, however our refrigerators will breakdown for the an initial six months, friend know, friend gotta break them in for awhile". Or "We intentionally build our new Ford trucks to jam up at highway speeds because that awhile--until it"s damaged in".I"d speak go v the one that cases to work-related properly from the box. Who can afford come waste 1000 ring doing R&D the manufacturer should have done?
A girlfriend of mine built six that the peak ten finishers 1911s at critical years Bianchi Cup. He division his guns in with 500 or so rounds before he offers them to a customer. As soon as you have everything fitted that specifically sometimes things have to be tweaked a little as the parts marry.Kimber ain"t building, or ever before will build, a gun in the course with what my girlfriend builds, so I"m not completely buying the 1000rd thing, but a couple of hundred ring isn"t an unreasonable request.
Forgive me mine nonsense, together I also forgive the rash of those that think they talk sense. Robert Frost
As ns re-read my short article I plainly had a brain fart. I meant that the Springfield armory 1911s are made both in the USA and Brazil.
S&W"s made in Brazil ? News to me too. ns do understand that S&W provides the frames for Kimbers and also it"s very own guns. I own a simple, dead nuts reputable Stainless Target practice Kimber. Never ever needed any type of breaking in. And also it shoots number of loads into 1.5-2 inches in ~ 25 yds. I"ve shot the S&W"s. Really destruction the create job our local smiths go on a buddy"s. And also I reaally prefer their grooved former strap. Also very accurate. If i were come buy another 1911, I"d most likely go through the smith. That"s due to the fact that they "talk come me" far better than most of the Kimbers for part reason. However I definitely wouldn"t rotate down a sweet Kimber either. E


See more: February 2017 Act Date S & Registration 2021, Sat & Act Test Dates & Deadlines

Kimbers guns are made by Jerico Precision manufacturing Corporation in Yonkers, brand-new York. If girlfriend look very closely at a S&W you�ll an alert that countless of the components are the same to those Jerico renders for Kimber and also Chip McCormick company; I�d it is in surprised if Jerico doesn�t make the frames together well, but who knows? know that in today�s 1911 market, virtually no one actually renders the entire pistol anymore, and also many machines don�t actually manufacture a solitary part, quite they assemble and also finish the components that become the gun. Taurus is the only device I understand of that actually makes the entire pistol, from forging frames to pins, springs, assembly finishing come market. Colt�s in reality forges frames for their 1911�s and also makes the major parts and many of the young parts. Colt�s union contract has some speak so in any parts that space out-sourced.Springfield buys both finished and 80% frames indigenous Imbel in Brazil. Follow to a gentleman I understand who has close connections to Imbel, if touring the Taurus factory he was shown a build that was turning out 1911 frame forgings and also he to be told castle were for Imbel. Many of the 1911�s made today space an assembly of many of the exact same parts. Therefore it yes, really comes under to that assembles the components best, or more consistently. This is why it�s frequently hard to say this 1911 is always far better than that 1911. Kimbers and S&W�s are damn near the very same gun, therefore it�s just a matter of who puts them with each other best. I right now own a S&W and I�ve shoot oodles of Kimbers end the years and also I open minded can�t speak one is �better� 보다 the other.